
XTR3M3
Member
Posts: 2602
|
ground zero mosque
Posted: Aug 19, 2010, 22:45:38
I find this whole thing nauseous. What a slap in the face to the people of New York that lost loved ones and the men and women that tried to rescue them. There are news reports that the building they want to buy actually had part of the landing gear of one of the planes that were crashed into the twin towers hit it. The Muslims say they want to create harmony and reach out to the community with this mosque.....are they freakin' stupid?!!! If they had any sensitivity at all and weren't completly selfish and self serving, they would not build it that close to the site of the greatest mass murder in American history perpatrated in the name of Islam...the faith they proclaim to serve.
The sad thing is, they might be completely oblivious and honestly want to spread good will but are so ingrained in the victim mentality that they can't see why 70% of us across America (not withstanding the most likey greater percentage in NY) think that is SERIOUSLY bad form to put it there. They can't see past their own perception that they are persecuted. It is as bad as erecting a shrine to Emperor Hirohito in Pearl Harbor in an attempt to share Japanese culture and good will. Hell, let's just put the statue right aboard the Arizona! Why not, we as Americans are suppose to accept everyone and not discriminate....sarcasm if you couldn't see it....
The perspective mosque site is said to be only about 600 feet away from ground zero.....that is LITERALLY in the shadow of the now destroyed twin towers.....and they call us insensitive......The politicians that are supporting this building site should be bitch slapped.
Should they be able to build their mosque? of course.... but only a bunch of insensitive, selfish bastards would build on that site that close to such an atrosity perpetrated in the name of the religion they serve when they don't HARSHLY condemn the rabid animals within their religion that did it. The lip service I have heard from these people about "they don't support what was done"....sounds just like that....lip service. I am not the only American that feels that way either....so do 70% of the rest of us....which would be about 250,000,000 others.
If they want Americans to embrace them, they need to get vocal and strenuously condemn this act and all other types of terrorism done in the name of Islam. The problem is that they don't vocally deal with these radical elements in their own faith without being pushed to do it. Only paying light, and I do mean light, lip service to not agreeing with the radicals only makes it seem to the rest of us that they secretly agree or support it. Is this the actual case? Probably not, but if they were truly wanting support, acceptance and good will...shouldn't they start being more vocal about the cancer spreading in their religion? Are all Muslims terrists? pfft! That is rediculous...of course they aren't. Are most of the worst terrorist acts being committed by self proclaimed Muslims? The numbers would support that. Until the Muslim leadership stands up and starts shouting down these radicals...this kind of back lash will probably continue. Perception is important in America and in lots of other countries around the world and until we can see that they are trying to stamp out large number of homicidal maniacs within their religion, the perception will continue to be that they are just looking the other way....best case scenario....or secretly support the views of the radicals.....whether that is true or not.
|

Tullsy
Board Admin
Posts: 2703
|
Re: ground zero mosque
Posted: Aug 20, 2010, 11:50:38
Look, I'm in no way saying that anything that the events that transpired in 2001 were in anyway ok, but as American's, we've, in a sense, built a ton of "Ground Zeros" next to Muslim Mosques. And we have since March of 2002.
This is issue is ridiculous. America is a free country and, as such, any religion, any peoples, can build and do what they want at any time and any place.
X, again, read the first line of this post, but you're stepping the line between religious tolerance and intolerance.
Quote: The Muslims say they want to create harmony and reach out to the community with this mosque.....are they freakin' stupid?!!! If they had any sensitivity at all and weren't completly selfish and self serving, they would not build it that close to the site of the greatest mass murder in American history perpatrated in the name of Islam...the faith they proclaim to serve.
Why are you putting all Muslims into one category? Why are you saying that every single one of them were, in some way, associated with these terrorists. Why are you saying that Muslims around the world were not affected in some way by the events that transpired in 2001?
Last Edited: Aug 20, 2010, 11:53:51
|

Xemnas
Board Admin
Posts: 1987
|
Re: ground zero mosque
Posted: Aug 20, 2010, 14:42:25
Quote: This is issue is ridiculous. America is a free country and, as such, any religion, any peoples, can build and do what they want at any time and any place.
So it would be alright if i erected a building in the middle of Islam by one of their ground zero that say "Get out of new york city Islamic people". And, they would alright with then? Even after the ridicule american's have shown tward's the Islamic nation, Religion, And they are just walk by like it's nothing.
It's hypocrisy on the Islamic people.
I know it sounds quite unfair to brand all as 1, But it's hard to swallow after the tragic event, It's hard to believe, let-alone trust the Islamic people.
It's like the Hispanic's that cross the boarder to get a job illegally. Not only did you break the law, You also screw over people's job. It's a double Negative problem.
If they really wanted to show us that they would like to show Harmony, 1st off DO NOT do it by the worst event in american history that your kind did (i don't mean that in a racial hate way just BTW) and expect us to let slide. It's Practically rubbing the event in our faces and laughing at us.
2nd, They need to do it elsewhere that doesn't harbor the event of 9/11 so we don't give them the evil eye or so it doesn't give us any bright idea.
If going to ground zero of 9/11 was their idea of sharing harmony with us. It's a bad one.
Last Edited: Aug 20, 2010, 14:43:34
|

Tullsy
Board Admin
Posts: 2703
|
Re: ground zero mosque
Posted: Aug 20, 2010, 15:14:20
Quote: So it would be alright if i erected a building in the middle of Islam by one of their ground zero that say "Get out of new york city Islamic people". And, they would alright with then?
This made absolutely no sense to me. Rephrase, please? Also, "Islam" isn't a place; It's a culture.
Quote: Even after the ridicule american's have shown tward's the Islamic nation, Religion, And they are just walk by like it's nothing.
Again, throwing them into one group. Only the extremists have "walked by like it's nothing." The rest, as American citizens or other, have felt the suffering and the pain that this event brought upon us. They weren't the perpitrators, they are merely part of the religion that we have placed a black mark upon.
Quote: I know it sounds quite unfair to brand all as 1, But it's hard to swallow after the tragic event, It's hard to believe, let-alone trust the Islamic people.
I just find this... hard to believe. Just because someone is, say, wearing a turban does not make them a bad person. Millions of Islamics lead healthy, prosperous lives. If I Canadian ran into an airport with a gun, the world would not blame Canadians nor would they claim that Canada is the root of all evil.
Quote: It's like the Hispanic's that cross the boarder to get a job illegally. Not only did you break the law, You also screw over people's job. It's a double Negative problem.
Unrelated, but sure. You have no idea what they are trying to escape by crossing the border. They are fleeing lives filled with violence, drugs and poverty. They are trying to start a new life. Yes, it's illegal, but isn't killing millions of innocent Iraqis, Arabs, Afghans and other peoples a war crime, even if it is unintentional.
Quote: If they really wanted to show us that they would like to show Harmony, 1st off DO NOT do it by the worst event in american history that your kind did (i don't mean that in a racial hate way just BTW) and expect us to let slide. It's Practically rubbing the event in our faces and laughing at us.
2nd, They need to do it elsewhere that doesn't harbor the event of 9/11 so we don't give them the evil eye or so it doesn't give us any bright idea.
If going to ground zero of 9/11 was their idea of sharing harmony with us. It's a bad one.
First, Why not? Religion has been, for the last 2000 years, the cohesive glue that binds us? Sure, we may have our differences, but it's brought us together through religious events like Easter, Christmas, Hanukkah, Lent, etc.
Second, the events of 9/11 were not done by the same group of people who are planning to build the Mosque. That event was not to promote a sense of harmony among Americans.
Third, they aren't laughing at us. They're saying that they want us, as Americans - you know, tolerant, nice people deep down - to forgive them, not those that thought that attacking the US on homesoil would be a good idea, but them - Muslims, Islamics, etc.
Fourth,
Quote: 2nd, They need to do it elsewhere that doesn't harbor the event of 9/11 so we don't give them the evil eye or so it doesn't give us any bright idea.
Errr?
|

XTR3M3
Member
Posts: 2602
|
Re: ground zero mosque
Posted: Aug 20, 2010, 21:44:08
I am really tired of that kind of "tolerant" crap Tullsy. Them building a mosque there is the WORST kind of insensitivity and bad form. How would they like it if we put a Christian church next to a bomb damaged mosque in Iraq? The screams of insensitivity from EVERY Islamic nation, and I dare say, probably most of the rest of the world, would be LOUD AS HELL. The world leaders would condemn us as insensitive and callous. Have you even listened to the imam proposing this? This imam, Feisal Abdul Rauf, made this comment on 60 minutes..."U.S. foreign policy was an "accessory" to the Sept. 11 attacks". What a freakin's slap in the face to the New Yorkers and the rest of America! Yea....that sounds like all they want is to spread goodwill and reach out to the community.
My analogy comparing this mosque to putting the statue of the emperor Hirohito of Japan that perpatrated the attack on Pearl Harbor during WWII on the remains of the USS Arizona is an acurate one. If these muslims truly wanted good will, they would take up the governor's offer to find them a different site. They refused of course.
I am tired of the mealy-mouthed crap about being tolerant of this kind of thing. I bet those of you who are "tolerant liberals" that don't have any problem with this mosque's location and think they should be able to build it there would think differently if it was your wife, your father, your sister, ect. that had to jump out of one of the twin towers to their death because it was better than burning to death. I also bet you would have a different view if you had to watch untold tons of steel and concrete crush your fellow firefighters and police officers that tried to save people. I am shocked and appalled that people can show sympathy to the "plight of these muslims" and be callously dismissive of those who have had to suffer so much in New York. Don't bother trying to dispute this saying "I wouldn't think any different if I did have relatives die".....because if you didn't you can't know and you would just be spouting more BS.
Anyone that would support this mosque site disgusts me....and they can take their politically correct ideals and shove them right up their arse.
*sometimes I really like not having to be a representative of SP so I can express my true opinions...
*edit* had to add "mosque" to "mosque site" in my last sentence that starts "Anyone that would support..." to avoid confusion using the context of my last sentence to lead someone to beleive I was talking about the SP site instead of my actual intention, the mosque site.
Last Edited: Aug 20, 2010, 21:56:46
|

shift944
Board Admin
Posts: 475
|
Re: ground zero mosque
Posted: Aug 20, 2010, 23:09:44
There is a huge difference between Islam and radical Islam. I know some very nice Muslim people. But Tullsy, what was it, not more than a few weeks ago 9 Christan aid workers were murdered in Afghanistan. They were not there to convert, they were there to solely provide humanitarian aid. If we tried to build a church in Afghanistan, every single worker would be shot to death and have their bodies paraded down the street. Every single Afghan civilian or tribe in that region would suffer as well.
I don't think its something to get so worked up over. People just want to respect the place where thousands of people died and which would soon result in thousands of more soldiers dying for them in some faraway land most people hardly even think of anymore.
Its not like were taking away a right, were just restricting it, just like gun control or free speech is, as posted in some other threads.
|

Tullsy
Board Admin
Posts: 2703
|
Re: ground zero mosque
Posted: Aug 23, 2010, 02:16:13
Quote: How would they like it if we put a Christian church next to a bomb damaged mosque in Iraq?
I can tell you that 90% of the population wouldn't give a damn. Why? Because they are rational, tolerant people. The group who you are referring to are known as the radicals and they are called as such for a reason. Not everybody in Afghanistan, Iraq and Iran are like them - they are disgusting, crude, vile people. However, and once again, you are putting all of Muslims and Islams into one group; this isn't right. I again bring in my analogy and, perhaps, fictitious anecdote about the Canadian in an airport with a gun. If he kills anybody, you would not blame Canadians, nor would you blame the person's religion. You would blame the guy. So, in this case, the case of 9/11, why are you blaming Muslims? I know a ton of well rounded, well educated and all around nice Muslims and Islamic people.
I know, this isn't the same as one man in an airport, and it is of bad taste to place a location of worship to the gods who, through living beings, carried out one of the greatest disasters in American history, but people have to stop blaming Iraqis and Afghans and start blaming those who are the real enemies of the state.
I'm not a liberal, I consider myself tolerant. It might be because of my country, but I think it's because I can think straight. I'm not saying that you're crazy or insane because you think that the location for this place of worship is ridiculous and a big mistake waiting to happen, but I think it's ridiculous that we're on the verge of asking for an exemption in the constitution so that a religious group can't build a church where they want.
Shift, you said it yourself. You answered your own question.
Quote: There is a huge difference between Islam and radical Islam.
Quote: If we tried to build a church in Afghanistan, every single worker would be shot to death and have their bodies paraded down the street.
You're right, they probably would be shot. But only by radicals.
|

XTR3M3
Member
Posts: 2602
|
Re: ground zero mosque
Posted: Aug 23, 2010, 11:33:11
Pull your head out....none of us are blaming all muslims for 9/11. Your "Canadian gunmen" analogy is not even close. Canadians don't consider us infidels that need to be converted of destroyed by any means necessary. Canadians take care of their own radicals, they don't secretly encourage or outright overtly encourge them to come here and bomb us. The Canadian ideology is not to convert the world to its point of view, by the sword if necessary either....so that analogy falls flat on its face.
You are WRONG if you think that 90% of people in an all muslim countries would be OK if we stuck a Jewish church next to a bombed mosque in their country. There would be demonstrations in the streets and the world would agree with them. Sure only the radicals would kill people in the church, but you are smoking something if you believe that the majority of the population would be OK with that.
Bah....really don't care what you think I guess....I am going to quote myself here...
Quote:
Anyone that would support this mosque site disgusts me....and they can take their politically correct ideals and shove them right up their arse.
Last Edited: Aug 23, 2010, 11:38:41
|

Tullsy
Board Admin
Posts: 2703
|
Re: ground zero mosque
Posted: Aug 23, 2010, 18:15:43
Quote: Pull your head out....none of us are blaming all muslims for 9/11. Your "Canadian gunmen" analogy is not even close. Canadians don't consider us infidels that need to be converted of destroyed by any means necessary. Canadians take care of their own radicals, they don't secretly encourage or outright overtly encourge them to come here and bomb us. The Canadian ideology is not to convert the world to its point of view, by the sword if necessary either....so that analogy falls flat on its face.
You are WRONG if you think that 90% of people in an all muslim countries would be OK if we stuck a Jewish church next to a bombed mosque in their country. There would be demonstrations in the streets and the world would agree with them. Sure only the radicals would kill people in the church, but you are smoking something if you believe that the majority of the population would be OK with that.
Bah....really don't care what you think I guess....I am going to quote myself here...
Quote:
Anyone that would support this mosque site disgusts me....and they can take their politically correct ideals and shove them right up their arse.
I never said I support it, and I respect your opinion. However, I find it a little odd that people still can't see the difference between radicals and everyone else. Ok, you're right, perhaps building a church in Iraq or whatever would exactly please the masses, but, in all fairness, they haven't been occupying our country for 9 years telling us how to run it.
If you weren't blaming all Muslims for the attack then why do you have a problem with them building the Mosque there? The people running it are not radicals, their aim is to show us that they are actually not all radicals.
Also, my analogy is sound. No one is telling people in Iraq how to live besides our own government. Nor do the majority of the Muslim population consider us infidels. It's all perspective. What you see in the news are extremists, people who put their god above their lives. Not everyone is like that, some people have a sense of what is right and what is wrong. Muslims don't try to convert the world - again, only the radicalists are attempting to do so by means of the sword.
Look, I'm not saying it's a great place to put that Mosque, however, as American's they have all the right to build that place of worship there. I'm not for condoning religion, I'm not a religious person, but I'm all for following the constitution.
|

Atrus
Board Admin
Posts: 293
|
Re: ground zero mosque
Posted: Aug 28, 2010, 13:40:02
As long as there are elements of the American culture that use fear and hate to service their ideology we will have these kinds of arguments.
What most seem to miss in this debate is why there is any debate at all? The building of this facility had been planned for some time, and there's already a Mosque four blocks away. The simple truth of the matter is this would not be an issue if it wasn't being used a political pawn in the upcoming mid-term election. Why now, why not make this an issue back years ago when the building was first purchased. Wake up folks, once again we're all being played, and the media makes it possible.
For me the bottom line here goes way back, back to when Bush first decided to form the DHS, to break-up or down all the systems and forces we had in place in the effort to prevent another 9/11. With every change, with every decision, with every action taken by fear and hate we became more fearful, and less American. Now today, after two wars unfinished, over four thousand dead, a trillion dollars wasted, a crippled economy, and no end in site, we argue over this. Did it ever occur to anyone that this type of argument is just what the Bin Laden's of the world want, need? How we perceive ourselves, our way of life, what we think and believe, all questioned and where deemed appropriate, changed.
So here's the question, how much longer are YOU willing to be changed. Ya see, for ME... I don't like the idea of being manipulated, especially by politicians using the media. And, we've already been changed enough as it is. What we should be arguing about is how we can allow this issue to breed, to grow, to morph into those things that are distinctly un-American. Next week, somewhere out in the mid-west a radio show host is sponsoring a burning of the Koran festival, and there are new state and local laws being proposed around the country to prevent the building of Mosque's, and to even tear down those already built. Fear and hate, just what the terrorists want from US.
Change is an essential process, we need change, but not the kind of changes that terror, fear, and hate brings. As for the Mosque, can they build it, YES... should they, I don't think so. But, keep in mind that NYC is a tough place, and WE ARE A TOUGH BUNCH. Don't allow fear or hate to shape your thinking. It's all about who WE are, and how we are to be understood. When you break it down and think it through, the sum of it all is the measure of pride and confidence taken from those who live in a country whose rule of law prevails over fear and hate.
Long live the Constitution of the United States of America.
|

deathscythe04
Member
Posts: 1291
|
Re: ground zero mosque
Posted: Aug 30, 2010, 13:21:00
the president supporting the mosque site is getting into the "seperation of church and state" that is supposed ot keep religion from effecting policy but i think obama made it clear he dont care about that part of the constitution probably cuz he is islamic!,which is where more BS is occuring cuz kids no longer do the pledge of allegiance in schools anymore cuz our politicians are dirty! i dont condone the mosque site 1 bit. it was ppl of middle eastern religion who did the 9/11 attacks and now ppl of middle eastern religion wanna build a religious relic less than 200 yrds from GZ that is not 1 bit politically correct despite a fair amount of our politicians being dirty as hell
|

Tullsy
Board Admin
Posts: 2703
|
Re: ground zero mosque
Posted: Aug 30, 2010, 21:03:33
Quote: Long live the Constitution of the United States of America. Bingo. This has and always should be the bottom line for discussions like this.
|

XTR3M3
Member
Posts: 2602
|
Re: ground zero mosque
Posted: Aug 31, 2010, 12:07:37
No one is saying it is against the law to build it there. No one is saying it should be against the constitution....geez. That is not even the issue. The issue is that they SHOULD NOT build it there, not that they CAN'T. Why even bring that up? As Americans, according to our constitution... for you people blindly fixated on the constitution end of this.... we have every right to protest this...Just like a church or elementry school would protest a strip club being built in its shadow. Can the strip club be built there? If it meets building ordinances, sure. Should it be built there? Hell no. This mosque has driven back American perception of Islamic relations almost a decade to almost as bad as after 9/11. This thing caused so many problems I have come to the conclusion that the people responsible are either complete brain donors, or are doing this on purpose to cause more conflict. Those are the only 2 logical choices since it is/was obvious to anyone that building it that close would cause a s**t storm of bad publicity.
Here is the thing. The Islamic community and the rest of the world are hypocritical as hell if they support this site. (not the mosque itself, just this site) If it was America doing something like this, and there are far more Muslims than Americans, the world would be running forward to condemn us. For crying out loud, if you tried to impose a reverse situation in the middle eastern countries...you would be shot in the street or end up with a bag on your head in a terrorist video.
We all agree that they can build this mosque there according to the laws and the constitution. This is the United States and if you meet building codes and ordinances, you can build what you want. If any of you think that they SHOULD build that war trophy of theirs at that site instead of a site more respectful of the citizens of New York, I am going to quote myself again...
Quote:
Anyone that would support this mosque site disgusts me....and they can take their politically correct ideals and shove them right up their arse.
|

Atrus
Board Admin
Posts: 293
|
Re: ground zero mosque
Posted: Aug 31, 2010, 16:50:25
I'm confused... there's already a Mosgue four blocks away. The proposed new location is two blocks away. Neither can be seen from the "Ground Zero".
I understand that the placement so close to that site is fuel to the fires of those who hate, but just how far back would be okay, and WHO do we put in charge of making that decision? One of these slippery slope type things going on here, ya know. If we're pissed off at this group of folks now restricting their rights, who will be next?
And again, WHO is making us pissed off, and why?
As for "Ground Zero" - when I was a kid we lived just outside of Washington D.C. in Northern VA. Like we could see the city lights in the sky at night. So close that the government thought it necessary to supply community's with post nulcear war provissions. In the basement of the building we lived in there was a real time air raid shelter. Big barrels of water, food, all kinds of supplies should there be war. At that time Washington D.C., thought to be first on the Soviet hit list, was referred to as ground zero. That name held aside for decades as the definition of a nuclear war strike location, until 9/11. But, a must have for the NEO-CON's wanting as much drama as possible after the towers fell.
God forbid there should ever be such an attack, but if it does happen, I guess we'll just have another ground zero, or would that be ground one.
~A
|

XTR3M3
Member
Posts: 2602
|
Re: ground zero mosque
Posted: Sep 2, 2010, 09:34:00
If you are having trouble remembering who....I know old people's memories sometimes aren't very good.....scroll up. That is also a nice typical liberal response with those key words "hate" and "intolerance". It is not about hate....there is no hate...just a sense of WRONGNESS a LOT of Americans are feeling now about putting that there. The only legit questions you did ask are.... how far away is OK? ....and who would make that decision?....Those are actualy good questions. I don't have the answers for that as I am not there. For me I guess....a willingness by muslim leaders of this mosque to actually consider another place and to acknowledge that this site as insensitive would have done it. Then I could have argued FOR them instead of against them. I bet that would be enough for most Americans. Instead they call us bigots and haters and ram this thing through which just pisses us off.
That other mosque was built before 9/11 BTW which is why there is no s**t storm surrounding it. Nice try on that lame re-direct. I don't get why some of the other mosques are being protested in other places though. The people protesting all mosques might fit into a "hate" category, but don't try and ignorantly cram me and others opposing JUST THIS mosque site (and probably the timing of it) into that same category.
It always seems like we are suppose to turn the other cheek. I only have 2 and they are all used up.....unless you count my bum...both bum cheeks are for kissing and are held lovingly in reserve for those of you who think we are bigots for not wanting this mosque to go up "as is". I have articulated my position very well. Don't mistake my passion about this for hate. If all you see is hate and bigotry, buy a seeing eye dog quick because you are blind as hell.
|

Atrus
Board Admin
Posts: 293
|
Re: ground zero mosque
Posted: Sep 2, 2010, 15:21:20
...sigh... someones knickers are in a twist, feeling the need to resort to personal attacks. That good old typical, and unfortunate "conservative" way to debate important social issues.
It's not about lib's or con's, not about what you or I think, not about how you or I feel. It is about that solider out there somewhere, serving America, putting his or her life on the line, ya know that one of the many Muslim volunteers, wearing the uniform, protecting our right to discuss these social issues. What do we say to them, or to the countless that have gone before. Or, what do we say to those Muslim families who lost loved ones when the towers fell?
I don't have the answers, all I know is I'm not playing the hate game, been there, done that. A Trillian Bucks, 4400+ dead, 40,000+ maimed and wounded. I've already said putting the Mosque there is not a good idea. But, there is such a larger issue at hand. It's about who we are, and what makes US different. I don't give a ratz azz if the Saudi's won't allow us to build a church in their country, what matters is that they can build one here. THIS IS WHO WE ARE, THIS IS WHY OUR WAY OF LIFE WILL PREVAIL.
Yes, I'm an old fossil and yes I'm going blind. Marty, hug a puppy... you'll feel better.
...end of line
Last Edited: Sep 2, 2010, 15:28:09
|

XTR3M3
Member
Posts: 2602
|
Re: ground zero mosque
Posted: Sep 3, 2010, 10:52:09
*smiles* You do the very thing you accuse me of....you just do it sneakier and more "generalized", but you still do it. That "conservative" reference was good....."liberals" tend to be more closed minded than conservatives. They think others not subscribing to their "ideology" are stupic, ignorant, haters, whatever..... if you don't believe the way they believe and roll over and play dead any time there is a conflict, you are labeled as bigots or Neo-cons. I live in one of the most liberal areas of the US, right next to Evergreen state college....where the "Greeners" references come from. Being conservative or Libertarian (which more accurately describes me) here is looked upon as a form of disease. I don't understand why you and others try to misdirect my opinion about this mosque site as hate. As I have said before...I will CLEARY itemize it so that it will be OBVIOUS it is only about this mosque site, not the mosque itself.....
#1 I could care less that Muslims want to build another mosque. Pouring that kind of money into the building trades and local economy is a good thing.
#2 I don't hate anything. I do however passionately disagree with the placement site of this mosque.
#3 They clearly have the right to build where ever they can meet city ordinances and acquire the building permits.
#4 I am all for the government staying out of this issue. I don't want them to prevent this site from happening. Them getting invovled sets a dangerous precedent.
#5 I do want the Muslims themselves to not build it there but somewhere else to show they truly have goodwill and the community in mind as they claim. If they don't, they just will prove the insensitive claim I and others have put forward.
"4400 dead...ect...ect.." and yet "we" need to be different and take the high road.... Well, I am tired of taking the high road. The US made mistakes in the conflict after 9/11, but we HAD to respond. The Muslim leadership is making one right now with this mosque. They are building this in America. I guess I would like them to take the stance that we are expected to take with them and be more sensitive. Their unwillingness to do so while at the same time demanding that we do smacks of hypocrisy to me.
I thoroughly enjoy these debates. It wouldn't be any fun if we all agreed. I wasn't personally attacking you A, just overtly doing what you were subvertly doing..... 
|

Atrus
Board Admin
Posts: 293
|
Re: ground zero mosque
Posted: Sep 8, 2010, 17:28:19
Normally, when I post "end of line" that's my way of saying I'm done with a thread, it's not worth the trouble. But, this one kinda bugs me because someone I have respected for some time has elected to use personal attacks. Not that I care about that, just the fact that they happened has me wondering?
Looking back over this thread I see where a few core sociological questions were asked, why we are angry about this, who benefits from our anger, if two blocks is too close then how far back would be okay, and who gets to decide, and what do we say to our Muslim friends and neighbors? Curious that no one felt the need to address any of these simple, but key questions.
Nope wasn't going to post here again, but something was said that keeps eating away at me. Something I just can't let go...
"It always seems like we are suppose to turn the other cheek. I only have 2 and they are all used up...."
Turn the other cheek... (pause) if 4,400+ DEAD, 40,000 WOUNDED, and a TRILLION dollars is turning the other cheek... well, God help anyone we decide to make war upon. And, let's not forget to mention the 1 MILLION displaced Iraqi families, over 100,000 DEAD, and unknown numbers of wounded.
One final question, then I suspect I really will just walk away from this thread... if we've been turning the other cheek, what do we say to the parents whose son gave his life for his country, or to the wife and children whose father is maimed and disabled for life? We turned the other cheek, you effing got to be kidding me.
In closing, I noted earlier how there was talk about some group burning the Koran. Well, ya have to live under a rock not to have heard the latest. This Pastor in Florida, on 9/11/2010, in response to the proposed building of the ground zero Mosque is sponsoring the "International Burn a Koran" event.
That's right folks, we're now burning books.
Fear and hate... the beat goes on.
|

radix
Member
Posts: 16
|
Re: ground zero mosque
Posted: Oct 2, 2010, 09:15:03
I beleive that this is really not the right thing to be building in such place, this actually anger's me that such a building will be built there. Not good at all.
|

Atrus
Board Admin
Posts: 293
|
Re: ground zero mosque
Posted: Oct 5, 2010, 18:24:21
I suspect everyone in this thread agrees it's a bad idea. My struggle, even with my own view, is why I think it's a bad idea.
The easiest thing to do is to feel anger for 9/11. The most difficult thing to do when so outraged, is to understand who we are and what we stand for.
My struggle to understand - continues.
|
|
Forum Home > Non-Gaming > Real Politik > ground zero mosque
|